SIG Design & Technology talks to Ian Dryden, Business Development Manager at SIG Roofing, about an increasing concern he has for flat roofs built in the 1980s and early 1990s, and incorrectly refurbished roofs which appear to be leaking, but they aren’t. Ian has been coming across a number of these roofs requiring refurbishment. They are suffering from a condition which has been misdiagnosed for years.
Ian was asked to inspect the roof of a 1980s built Glasgow School which had been leaking for well over 16 years, but the leak could not be found. The 3000m2 flat roof at the school was constructed with a composite panel used as a deck together with a pre-laminated underlay. Several overlays of new membrane have been applied over the years, each without success.
Ian inspected the roof by taking a number of core samples and discovered that there was no VCL (vapour control layer) in the construction. He then inspected a lap between the composite panels and discovered there was no butyl mastic seal to the laps either. When the roof was designed the designers may have argued that there was no need for a VCL as the panel is factory bonded, but every lap and penetration through the deck should have been fully sealed with butyl mastic. If there is no control to water vapour travelling through the roof, then it is at risk of interstitial condensation.
What is Interstitial Condensation?
Condensation is when water vapour condenses into liquid. This is seen, for example, when a cold glass of water meets warm, moist air. Droplets of water collect on the surface where the lower temperature produces an energy transfer from the water vapour to the colder surface, and the vapour condenses into a liquid at that surface.
“Interstitial” means occupying “interstices” – small gaps or cracks. So Interstitial condensation occurs within the fabric of a building, at the point (known as the dew point), where the atmospheric temperature of a given concentration of water vapour drops to a point when water droplets begin to condense and dew can form.
Interstitial condensation is different from surface condensation such as that caused by cold bridging, and its occurrence within the roof or wall structure of a building is difficult to detect without investigation.
What Interstitial Condensation can do?
After inspecting the whole roof of the Glasgow school, Ian had to conclude that there was no way for the water to get into the roof other than condensing out of the water vapour travelling up through it. The remaining roof structure was correctly detailed, there were no weep holes for water to get in, and the waterproofing was in excellent condition. Wherever you cut a hole in the roof, it was saturated with water inside.
The costs of misdiagnosis were high. Every so often 30-40m2 of ceiling tiles had to be replaced as they became ruined by the leaks. The water followed the troughs in the metal deck, tracked along the laps and leaked under the gutters, the lowest point. As a result, a leaking gutter had been suspected, and long lengths of gutter had been re-felted to no effect – the water kept coming. Indeed, a complete overlay of the roof with an additional membrane increased the vapour resistivity of the surface and compounded the condensation problem.
With 2000 children breathing in the school for sixteen years, the considerable additional weight of all that water can also put significant load on the roof. This amounts to an annual moisture accumulation of 0.44kg/m2, or nearly half a litre a year in every square metre of roof.
This is just one of Ian’s projects. In another school with a cold roof, a 250mm unventilated ceiling void has caused the timber deck to rot from the inside. For 5 or 6 years the 1600m2 deck has gradually rotted and now 90% of the timber deck has completely failed. If the problem had been identified earlier the deck would have been saved, but now the entire roof including the deck will have to be replaced.
How to find out if you have Interstitial Condensation?
What to do if you come across a leaking roof from the 1980s/90s or a roof from that period that has been overlaid? Here is Ian’s advice.
1. Have a proper investigation
Don’t assume that the leak is coming from a failed membrane, or a leaky gutter – you may be mistaken. Make sure an experienced specialist is involved in investigating the leak. They will cut a core sample – a hole in the roof which will enable them to identify the buildup and check the condition of the layers of roof.
2. Look for a VCL
The core sample will enable your specialist to check for a VCL. If there is no Vapour Control Layer, there is a very good chance that interstitial condensation may be the cause.
3. Look for Seals on a Metal Deck
If the roof is constructed of composite sheets on a metal deck, check whether they are fully sealed. They may not be the case, especially if the roof was constructed in the 1980s and early 1990s. If the seals are not there, warm air may be travelling up inside the construction and condensing where it hits the dew point.
4. Cold Roof? Check the Ceiling Void is Ventilated
If there is a ceiling void, especially with a cold roof, is it ventilated? Many were not in this period, and without ventilation warm moist air will condense onto a timber deck and rot the roof from the inside.
5. Get an Interstitial Condensation Risk Analysis
Get an Interstitial Condensation Risk Analysis carried out. This is something we do for all our new roofs as well, as part of our design service. The analysis will determine the dew point and you can check where the condensation is happening in the report. If the dew point is within the buildup, you have a problem.
6. Determine if you’ve got a leak or condensation
If all your investigations come back fine, then a leak is most likely the cause. “Even when I find an obvious leak, I always check the dew points,” says Ian. “Some of the VCLs were made to BS7471f and 1b which are little more than a vapour check.” The lack of a proper metal lined VCL can lead to a swimming pool on your roof.
7. Don’t forget to check with Roof Refurbishment Overlays
When you’ve determined the cause of water arriving inside the building, you’re in a position to make appropriate repairs. But when refurbishing a roof, make sure you carry out an interstitial condensation risk analysis on the new buildup to make sure that it will not result in condensation within the structure.
“I think people have forgotten what an important issue interstitial condensation is.” Ian told us, “you must make sure you take the dew point right to the top of the buildup”. Make sure you ask for the report, and check it carefully. “Architects often ask me why I’m putting 100mm insulation in a refurbishment rather than 50mm” says Ian. “You may not know about the condensation for 10 or 15 years, until the roof caves in.”
